October 27, 2020 [Day 437] Appeal Hearings Begin in Moscow City Court (SEE TRIALS/APPEALS page for more details)
The first level of appeals began today in the Moscow City Court. This would be similar to a State level court in the U.S. There were two hearings scheduled for today; 1) Appeal of conviction and 9 year sentence in Golovinsky District Court, 2) Appeal of the Golovinsky District Court's denial to investigate Trevor's claim regarding his "bodily injuries" sustained during his initial arrest.
1) The main appeal was postponed after the defense presented information about no translated verdict being presented to Trevor, and numerous errors in translation of the transcripts and missing documents. Postponed until November 11, 2020.
2) The appeal of the Golovinsky District Court's denial to investigate Trevor's claim of injuries during his arrest was heard and dismissed by a different judge. She said that it would be part of the main appeal. (His rights to have his complaint investigated have been denied by the investigator, prosecutors, and the Golovinsky District Court judge. They consider the police officers the "victims" and not Trevor. )
1. Continual problems getting Trevor over-the-counter medications for medical issues.
2. Trevor not allowed to make phone calls to his family as other prisoners.
3. Trevor must write and receive all letters in Russian language.
4. For almost 1 year, Trevor denied a foam bed pad for severe back pain even though other prisoners are allowed them.
5. In September during one of two family visits per month, he was removed from his cube and moved to a holding cell away from his Dad and Lina for about 15 minutes. No reasons given.
United States Ambassador to the Russian Federation, John Sullivan, made a short visit with Trevor today. Trevor was in good spirits and glad to see him. Trevor updated the Ambassador on his condition and issues that he is having getting some medicines, proper bedding, phone calls with family, and a recent interference with his family visit.
This was Ambassador Sullivan's first time to meet Trevor. They had a good meeting and the Ambassador got to visit with Trevor not only about his situation and needs, but also about his family, school, and his future. We are very thankful for the Ambassador visiting Trevor and holding a press conference outside the prison following the visit.
July 24, 2020 [Day 344] (Attorneys Meet with Trevor and Arrange for Medicines to be accepted)
The attorneys were allowed to meet with Trevor at SIZO-5. They were allowed to have a room with him instead of visiting through the glass as had been done for several months during the pandemic. Following the meeting, the attorneys met with prison officials and cleared up an internal communications problem between doctors that had been preventing Trevor from receiving over the counter medications he needed for medical issues. The embassy still has never received any medical documents from the jail that were requested on March 27th.
The trial continued today with audio and video evidence presented. One witness testimony was read. Requests for defense expert witnesses were made and approved by the Judge.
The trial continued today after almost four months of pandemic delays. We will post some details from the hearing in the trials section in the next few days.
June 30, 2020 [Day 320] (Hearing Cancelled)
The trial hearing for today was postponed for the sixth time since March 11th. This was due to prisoners not being allowed to leave the jail due to possible virus contamination. We have been told that starting tomorrow, July 1, prisoners will be allowed to leave the jail to attend their trials. Trevor trial is scheduled to continue at 11:00 AM on Thursday, July 2nd.
June 18, 2020 [Day 308] (No Changes To Report)
Trevor is anxious to get his trial started again and get it over with. It is unclear if prisoners will be allowed to leave the jail for court by June 30th. The family is very thankful for news reports about Trevor's situation. We want to clarify that we have not made any demands of any government or officials. That would be counterproductive. We work respectfully within the laws and procedures of both the Russian Federation and United States of America in an effort to have the fairest trial possible.
June 1, 2020 [Day 291] (Trial was postponed until June 30th and July 2nd, 5th postponement!)
The trial hearing set for June 2nd has been postponed again. Prisoners are still not being allowed to leave the jails and return because they might expose the prison population to the virus. The new tentative date of Tuesday, June 39th and July 2nd, 2020 has been scheduled for the next trial date. The Embassy still has not been able to communicate with Trevor nor have they received any medical information from the jail.
May 25, 2020 [Day 284] (Trial was postponed until June 2nd, 4th postponement!)
The trial hearing set for May 26th has been postponed again. Prisoners are still not being allowed to leave the jails and return because they might expose the prison population to the virus. The new tentative date of Tuesday, June 2nd, 2020 has been scheduled for the next trial date. The Embassy still has not been able to communicate with Trevor nor have they received any medical information from the jail.
May 13, 2020 [Day 271] (Trial was postponed until May 26, 3rd postponement!)
The government has ordered the courts to resume regular cases. However, Prisoners are not allowed to leave the jails and return because they might expose the prison population to the virus. In Trevor's court, either the courtroom is not able to utilize video conferencing with the jail, or the defendant must be present in person for criminal trials, or both. We are unsure of the exact reason for the postponement at this time. We are also unsure if prisoners will be released from jail for courts by May 26. Even though the civilian lockdown in Moscow is beginning to open, there may still be concerns about infections inside the crowded prisons and jails.
April 22, 2020 [Day 251] (Appeal Hearing related to Bail, Moscow City Court)
Today was Trevor’s sixth bail appeal hearing in the past seven months. (See the “Denied Bail/Supreme Court” heading for past details). Today in court, Trevor’s father was questioned by the defense and the judge. The prosecutor had no questions for the father. The defense identified several sections of the 450+ page case file for the judge to read in court. Then, the defense attorneys argued numerous points including the opinions of the Supreme Court and the Court of Cassation that opposed Trevor’s bail being withdrawn. They made arguments for approximately 45 minutes. The prosecutor, who we had not seen before and was probably unfamiliar with the case, argued her points for just under two minutes. Trevor was then asked if he had any statements and he brought direct examples of why the prosecutor’s arguments should be invalid including quoting the decision of the Supreme Court related to registration. The judge deliberated for approximately 10-15 minutes and ruled that Trevor should remain in jail and not be granted bail or house arrest. Tomorrow, we will post the specific arguments raised by both sides and the judge’s comments related to the ruling.
April 20, 2020 [Day 249] (Appeal court was postponed until April 22)
The defense interpreter was not allowed to be present in court today. Then the court appointed interpreter was not able to perform, so the hearing had to be rescheduled for Wednesday, April 22)
April 17, 2020 (We received notification that Trevor's next appeal hearing for Bail will be held on Monday, April 20th, in Moscow City Court)
This is the continuation of the appeal process that has already been to the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and the 2nd Court of Cassation of General Jurisdiction.
April 15, 2020 (Trial Postponed until May 13, 2020)
The trial has been postponed until May 13, 2020. It is our understanding that some courts will begin hearing cases again in April, but this is not confirmed. There has been no news about the next appeals court date for the ongoing argument regarding the method of detention (Bail or Home Arrest). Even though a Moscow City Court granted bail, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation determined that bail was withdrawn in violation of the law, and the 2nd Court of Cassation of General Jurisdiction agreed with the Supreme Court findings, Trevor is still being held in jail pending yet another appeal hearing at the Moscow City Court where the original bail was granted seven months ago.
March 27, 2020
Trevor's father delivered food to SIZO-5 for Trevor. His father attempted to deliver hand sanitizer and antibacterial hand wipes along with other supplies. The antibacterial products were rejected at the main transfer window and also later in the day by medical staff. The jail had already stopped visitations with prisoners on about March 17-18 due to Coronavirus restrictions, but as of March 27, was still accepting food, clothing, and medications.
March 25, 2020
Trevor had a syncopal episode on March 25th sometime after his court appearance. He was unconscious briefly. Medical staff said that his blood pressure was in the neighborhood of 80?/50? and his pulse rate was around 50. These are not his normal vital signs. He notified his attorneys via video during an appeal hearing held the following day. On March 27th, the U.S. Embassy submitted an official "Urgent" request for medical information related to Trevor's condition. As of June 1, the Embassy has not received this information.